Melton Your Mouth Pork Pie

Melton Mowbray Pork Pie

In 1994, and after six playfully-humorous seasons of barbershop-based banter, fans of British-Caribbean sitcom “Desmond’s” were disappointed when the show was discontinued. This blow may have been softened when they learned that it was to be succeeded by spin-off show “Porkpie”, but, after two fairly insipid seasons, this too was consigned to the bin of history, in part, because it relied on the exact same jokes as its predecessor. Never a regular watcher of Desmond’s, I was still sufficiently aware of it to be familiar with at least one of the leading characters.

Porkpie, played by Guyana-born actor and musician “Ram” John Holder, led the supporting cast in Desmond’s as a part of the furniture at the barbershop, always ready with a pithy remark or grumpy wisdom. Nicknamed for his habit of sporting a squarish leather fedora, known as a pork pie hat due to its resemblance to a kind of thick-crusted meat pie, Porkpie was a retired Ford employee turned-lollipop man from Peckham, south London. Porkpie’s eponymous show began with him borrowing a quid off his nephew to buy what turned out to be a winning lottery ticket. So that his nephew could not lay claim to his new fortune, Porkpie was careful to repay the loan before announcing his win. A series of spurious capers and intrigues around Porkpie’s experiences as a newly-minted millionaire followed, most of which centered on him trying to hang on to his money while his nearest and dearest, together with unscrupulous characters from his past, including an ex-wife who immigrates from Jamaica after reading of his good fortune in the West Indian Times, are determined to wrest it from him one way or another.

It is this show, then, that I can’t help bring to mind every time I think of the actual dish of pork pie – a Boxing Day favorite in my house growing up. And because of that, it is always feigning a (terrible) West Indian accent that I utter the words “pork pie”. However, as far as I know, at no point during the combined eight seasons of Desmond’s and Porkpie was an actual pork pie seen on camera. This might not be surprising since the pork pie is not a Caribbean dish nor is it from London, but for British food fans and those among us who prefer our humor painfully obvious it was a pity.
Pork pie
Pork pie
Pork pie

In basic terms, pork pie is a circular confection of fresh and preserved minced pork, flavored subtly with thyme, sage, nutmeg, cloves and white pepper, and wrapped in aspic and hot water pastry. Once baked it has the consistency of an old brick – stiff, brown and slightly crumbly on the outside, but pinker, dense and heavy in the center. It’s unrepentantly traditional and old-fashioned. The pastry requires pork lard and the filling combines three different kinds of pork meat. It’s food for the agricultural laborer that has not, and in many ways, cannot be modernized without fundamentally changing it.

Thankfully, modern is not a word frequently associated with pork pies. Hailing from the gastronomic triangle between Nottingham, Lincoln and Leicester from which the world-class – and traditionally-made – cheeses stilton and red leicester also originate, pork pies from the market town of Melton Mowbray are still being made in the centuries-old way. So much so, that they were recently the recipients of a Protected Geographical Indication by the European Union. Under this designation only pies using the “hand-raised” technique that produces the hard, crumbly crust can be officially-titled Melton Mowbray pork pies.

One might mistake pork pie for its continental cousin of paté en crôute and there certainly are similarities, both in the sense that they are slightly intimidating and time-consuming to prepare and have curiously pink centers, even after baking. I’d also consider pork pie a sort of preserved meat, as I would paté, in part because they are robed in aspic, but the similarity is really that they inhabit the same culinary niche – that of the slightly-elevated rib-sticker that’s best served cool with vinegary condiments and crunchy salads.

In my family, it was ubiquitous on the Boxing Day table, alongside cold-cuts and other side dishes from the previous day’s roast, Branston pickle, and salad cream. Not exactly an antidote to heavy Yuletide fare, but a change in temperature, at least. My favorite way of serving it – even today – is to bathe a fat slab of pork pie with hot brown gravy so that the pastry starts to soften, but the center is still cool, though I’m prepared to accept that not everyone will find that combination so toothsome.

Pork pie is also commonly taken alongside a limp salad during what we British jokingly refer to as the summer – those months from June-August when the rain is slightly warmer. It’s because of its reassuring nature that I consider pork pie among my favorite British dishes, and I can’t help but think that the show “Porkpie” might have stood an improved chance of renewal for season 3 had the set-managers taken it upon themselves to scatter said pies – personal or family-sized – in various scenes. It certainly wouldn’t have made for cornier gags than those they were already using.

Melton Mowbray-style* Pork Pie
Serves 10-12 comfortably
Adapted from The Cooking of the British Isles and BBC Food’s “raised pork pie” recipe

*traditional Melton Mowbray pork pies do not contain boiled eggs

For the hot-water pastry:

  • 5 cups all-purpose flour
  • 15 tablespoons fresh rendered pork lard at room temperature
  • 8 tablespoons of milk
  • 8 tablespoons of water
  • 1/2 teaspoon of salt

For the filling:

  • 1.7lb fresh minced pork
  • 0.8lb fresh pork belly
  • 1/2lb smoked bacon
  • 6 large eggs
  • 0.5 teaspoons of ground mace
  • 2 large pinches of ground nutmeg
  • 1.5 teaspoons salt
  • 1 tablespoon chopped sage (dry or fresh)
  • 1 teaspoon chopped fresh thyme
  • 2 teaspoons white pepper
  • 2 pints warm stock – chicken, vegetable or pork work fine
  • 2 packets of flavorless gelatin


For the pastry:

  1. Combine water and lard in saucepan and heat until lard is liquid and hot to the touch, but not boiling
  2. In a large mixing bowl sift flour and salt together, before beating in lard and water mixture a few tablespoons at a time.
  3. Continue until dough forms (use of hands is easier than a spoon after a while, though the pastry hook on your mixer would also work).
  4. Then kneed the dough until smooth and dense, 3-5 minutes.
  5. Note: You may not need all the lard, milk and warm water mixture depending on the humidity in your kitchen.
  6. Place dough under a dampened cloth somewhere warm but not hot to rest for 30-45 minutes.
  7. Once rested, carefully roll out dough, reserving 1/4 of it for the pie lid.
  8. Then line a circular greased (or non-stick) springform baking dish with the rolled out pastry being careful not to let it get too thin.
  9. Gently spoon in pork filling (see below), pausing halfway to place boiled eggs in playful arrangement, before covering with rolled-out remaining pastry. Make sure to properly crimp the edges and make a steam hole in the top.
  10. Place on a baking try and in a 350F/175C oven for 1.5hrs
  11. Remove from oven and allow to cool completely.
  12. In a saucepan stir warm stock and gelatin together making sure they are completely dissolved in one another.
  13. Using a funnel carefully pour the stock into the pie via the steam-hole. Allow to sit in refrigerator for up to 12hours or until aspic has set.
  14. Un-mold your pie carefully and slice with a very sharp knife (serrated knives are good), and serve with a green salad and your choice of pickled condiments.

For the filling:

  1. Either finely chop or use the sausage attachment to your mixer to get the bacon and pork belly to the right consistency – think sausage meat.
  2. Then place it in a large bowl with the minced pork and season with sage, thyme, nutmeg, white pepper and salt. Mix well by hand. Then run mixture through sausage attachment again to ensure uniform consistency and seasoning.
  3. (optional)Place filling in muslin bag and suspend over a pot in your fridge overnight to drain excess moisture.
  4. Boil eggs until fully-cooked, about 8 minutes. Remove and place in iced water until fully cool.
  5. Follow steps 8-12 above and get to pork pie heaven.

9 thoughts on “Melton Your Mouth Pork Pie

  1. When I hear the words “pork pie” I think of the “savory pork pie” in “Great Expectations” that Pip stole to feed Magwitch – much to his sister’s displeasure. I would love for him to steal this for me. It looks delicious. One can never have too much pork. I also need to stick that TV show in my Netflix queue.

  2. @Rachel (S[d]OC): I have no recollection of the stolen pork pie from Great Expectations, but I can well understand Mrs. Joe’s displeasure at having her pork pie pinched to feed that ne’er do well Magwitch, even if he did turn out well in the end. You may like Desmond’s. It’s actually quite humorous in a predictable sort of way, and gives a bit of insight into what Caribbean immigrant communities in Britain are like. Be warned though, it’s not exactly a roll-on-the-floor experience.

  3. It must have been a challenge chowing down on that thing wearing boxing gloves! hahaha, just a little colonist humour–:)
    Yours looks like a very high elevation of this dish right down to the lovely decoration on the crust. And I’ll bet it would be good with a nice tangy cole slaw! The egg is a nice touch too, and looks pretty to boot.
    (I wonder if I could try maling a very low-brow version using the always in stock Spam here in the islands? I’ll let you know!)

    1. @Deb: I wouldn’t rule out the inclusion of spam. Frankly, a personal pork pie might be made perfectly with a can of spam and the jelly it comes in inserted into a pre-baked crust. Served with some coleslaw, grilled pineapple rings and some fried taro, it would be the ideal Hawaiian picnic food.

  4. I never know which I like better, your recipes or your stories.
    Pork pies are so ENGLISH. I think I’ve only had 2 decent ones in my life and most are ghastly (they were both mini-individual pies). You make me want to give it another try with your serving tip. Happy new year!

    1. @Deana: there are plenty of rough pork pies to be found at service stations throughout Britain. Similarly, bastardized versions of Cornish pasties. The real things are a different beast altogether and I would encourage you (of all people) to give it a try.

    1. @Jullian: thanks for stopping by and for your kind words. You may have seen our photo on Instagram, in fact. Let us know if you try the recipe and how it works out. (Just beware that the flour | fat | liquid ratios in the pastry may vary depending on the ambient humidity and altitude.)

Like this post? Hate this post? Let us know!